MLB The Show 25 Pitchers: Who Will Get The Highest Rating?
Posted: Mar 04, 2025 Views: 194
MLB The Show 25 is expected to be released on the 18th of this month. More information about the players will be released one after another this week. So before the player ratings are released, let’s predict how many points these outstanding players will get in the game.
Overall Rating 97
- Tarik Skubal: Starting Pitcher, LHP, Tigers
- Chris Sale: Starting Pitcher, LHP, Braves
Tarik Skubal only received an overall rating of 86 in MLB The Show 24 because of his unsatisfactory performance in 2023. Although he also played some highlights, many people thought he was just a flash in the pan.
However, Tarik Skubal’s performance in 2024 severely slapped the faces of those who doubted his ability. He achieved 6.3 WAR (MLB best), 18 wins (MLB best), 2.39 ERA (MLB best) and 228 strikeouts (MLB best) in the year. His performance shocked the league and won him the American Cy Young Award. Given his performance in 2024, 97 points is definitely not excessive.
Chris Sale is a veteran on the field, and many people thought he had retired. In fact, he has played very little since 2019 and his performance has been very mediocre. MLB The Show 24 gave him a score of 85 points.
Due to the accidental injury of Braves star player Spencer Strider, the veteran replaced him and defeated Spencer Strider’s opponent Zack Wheeler to win NL Cy Young Trophy.
The performances of these two pitchers in 2024 are legendary, but since their performances are not very stable, 97 points is a more suitable score for them. They are without a doubt the pitchers you should invest in with MLB The Show 25 Stubs.
Overall Rating 96
- Zack Wheeler: Starting Pitcher, RHP, Phillies
- Paul Skenes: Starting Pitcher, RHP, Pirates
Zack Wheeler has been very close to the top of Cy voting in three seasons. He received a high rating of 93 in The Show 24. Zack Wheeler outdid himself last season, so he deserves a higher score than 93.
But Zack Wheeler is almost 35 years old and is no longer in his prime. And he was beaten by Spencer Strider, so the score is lower than 97.
Paul Skenes’ game data is slightly lower than Zack Wheeler’s, but he is very young. His pitching career is still on the rise. As long as he stays healthy, his rating may continue to rise.
Overall Rating 95
- Corbin Burnes: Starting Pitcher, RHP, Diamondbacks
- Emmanuel Clase: Closer Pitcher, RHP, Keeper
Corbin Burnes is at his peak. His stats in 2024 are consistent with his previous performances. Corbin Burnes has been in the top ten of Cy Young Award voting for five consecutive years. Corbin Burnes’ stats in 2023 are not outstanding, but his pitching performance is excellent. His overall rating in The Show 24 is only 88, which is obviously underestimated. This mistake should be corrected in MLB The Show 25.
Emmanuel Clase is a very good Closer Pitcher. He has 47 saves in 74 games, an ERA of 0.61 and a win share of 4.4. This performance puts him third in American League Cy Young Award voting. According to Emmanuel Clase’s stats in 2024, 95 points may be a suitable score.
Overall Rating 94
- Spencer Strider: Starting Pitcher, RHP, Braves
- Frambell Valdez: Starting Pitcher, LHP, Astros
Spencer Strider was once a pitcher who could compete with Zack Wheeler, or even be better. His overall rating in MLB The Show 24 was an amazing 97. But injuries have severely affected him. Spencer Strider has barely pitched since 2023. His physical fitness may have declined, which may cause him to fall out of the 95 overall rating team. If you still miss Spencer Strider’s glory days, then save your MLB The Show 25 Stubs for him.
Frambell Valdez is the most consistent pitcher. In the past five years, Framber Valdez has participated in Cy Young Award competition four times and won MVP votes in two of them. But MLB The Show tends to underestimate Framber Valdez, who deserves a better overall rating.
Overall Rating 93
- Gerrit Cole: Starting Pitcher, RHP, Yankees
Gerrit Cole’s performance in 2023 was his peak, and he was considered one of the best pitchers. However, his performance in 2024 was slightly worse. Gerrit Cole’s score in 2024 was 95 and in 2023 was 90, so his Overall in MLB 25 can be reasonably guessed to be somewhere between these two numbers.
Overall Rating 92
- Blake Snell: Starting Pitcher, LHP, Dodgers
- Cole Ragans: Starting Pitcher, LHP, Royals
- Tanner Scott: Closer Pitcher, LHP, Dodgers
Blake Snell is a capable player who won the Cy Young Award in 2023. However, MLB The Show only gave him an 84. This is obviously a very unreasonable score. Blake Snell should try to pick up. Although it is not at the top level, Blake Snell’s Overall 92 is definitely not excessive.
Tanner Scott’s score in 2024 is 91, and his WAR last season was 4.0, so his score should be one point higher than last year’s 91.
Cole Ragans is the ace pitcher of Royals. He ranked fourth in American League Cy Young Award. Cole Ragans leads all American League pitchers in strikeout rate. This could push his overall rating above 90.
In addition to the pitchers listed above, there are many more pitchers that are not included. You can choose to invest MLB The Show 25 Stubs in the highest-rated players to strengthen your team. You can also choose to unlock your favorite players to build a dream team. This game cannot be won by one player, and try to build the team you want most in MLB 25!
Recommended Article
-
MLB The Show 25 Player Ratings: Which Players Are The Best?
-
MLB The Show 25 Diamond Dynasty: What Updates Will This Main Mode Get?
-
MLB The Show 25 Franchise Mode: What New Behaviors Do You Have As A General Manager In This Improved Mode?
-
MLB The Show 25 Franchise Mode: What Changes Are Worth Looking Forward To?
-
MLB The Show 25: Will You Be Happy With These Upcoming New Contents?